Receive the weekly sampler of posts and "Resource of the Week".
Subscribe »

Enter your
email address:

My Account »


Bookmark and Share

Testimonial?
If you find ResourceShelf useful, please supply a testimonial »








Home > ResourceBlog > Article

« All ResourceBlog Articles

 

Bookmark and Share   Feed

Monday, 6th July 2009

News Websites in Texas and Kentucky Invoke Shield Laws for Online Commenters

News Websites in Texas and Kentucky Invoke Shield Laws for Online Commenters

This week brings word of two new cases testing whether state shield laws apply to user comments posted on news websites. In Texas, a Taylor County District Court judge ruled that the Abilene Reporter-News may refrain from disclosing the identities of commenters who posted comments to articles about a murder victim and the teenager charged in connection with his death. According to a follow-up story by the Reporter-News, defense counsel in the criminal case had sought the commenters' identities to make sure they weren't chosen as jurors in the trial, which began last week.

Details of the Texas court's decision are sketchy, but reports indicate that the Reporter-News invoked Texas's newly minted shield law, as well as the commenters' First Amendment rights to speak anonymously. The new Texas shield law expressly covers Internet news media and grants protection for both the identity of sources and unpublished materials obtained or prepared while acting as a journalist. See Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code §§ 22.021, -.023; Tex. Crim. Proc. Code § 38.11, Sec. 3(a)(1)-(2). (For more details on the Texas shield law, see RCFP's informative post.) When we get a hold of a transcript of the court's ruling, it will be interesting to see whether the court characterized the website commenters as "sources" and, if so, how the court justified this characterization.

In Kentucky, a college student filed a John Doe lawsuit and subpoenaed The Richmond Register, seeking the identity of a commenter going by "12bme," who posted a comment on a forum linked to an August 12, 2008 story on the newspaper's website. The news story reported on the college student's ejection from a local mall for wearing a dress -- which she had purchased there -- that mall security deemed too short. According to the Louisville Courier-Journal, 12bme's comment claimed that the student actually was removed because she "had exposed herself to a woman and her children who remarked on the dress." The student maintains that this comment was false and defamatory and seeks 12bme's identity in order to proceed with her lawsuit.

Source: Citizen Media Law Project


Category:

Views: 505




blog comments powered by Disqus

« All ResourceBlog Articles

 

Read about the FreePint FamilyFreePint Family

A family of resources to help information workers be more effective, raise the value of information in their organisations and contribute to success. Read more »


FeedLatest Family Articles:


Click to view the article Quilting big data threads
Thursday, 24th May 2012

Recently I have found myself cooing over visualisation maps (and heat maps) of health and well being resources. The content rich data is overlayed with mapping technologies, and some interesting themes and patterns are emerging.


Click to view the article The fallacy of information overload
Wednesday, 23rd May 2012

A lot of the talk around social media in the last year has been around information overload. Social media has provided us with new and exciting ways to create content. But it has also meant learning new ways to manage and engage with social media tools. Are we teetering on the edge of an information overload precipice?


Click to view the article Information overload: fact, fantasy or filter failure?
Wednesday, 23rd May 2012

Information overload is a figment of your imagination. Or a failure of your filter. Or a symptom of your technological submissiveness. Depends on who you ask.


Click to view the article Newsdesk: tracking millions of pieces of information a day
Tuesday, 22nd May 2012

What if you had to sort through 3.5 million articles and social media posts a day and try to pull out the most relevant items for your organisation? What if you then had to cobble it all together into something readable for your top groups and executives in your organisation?


Click to view the article Alacra Compliance adds managerial oversight
Tuesday, 22nd May 2012

Alacra Compliance saves time by aggregating information from both free and fee-based sources and enabling users to conduct an accurate federated search across these sources (coined “simultaneous search” by Alacra).


All Family Articles »
Family Articles by Category »


Tell us what you're working on,
and we'll talk to you about how FreePint can help »


FreePint Family Testimonials

"Fabulous resource to learn of unique tools and insights. Very useful." Manager, Futures and Forecasting, Virginia, USA

More testimonials »






Subscribe

Subscribe to the ResourceShelf Newsletter and receive the weekly sampler of posts and Resource of the Week.

Find out more »

ResourceShelf sponsored by:

Article Categories

All Article Categories »

Archive

All Archives »